
The Round Up (1920)
Director: George Melford
Screenplay: Tom Forman; adapted from the play by Edmund Day
Stars: Roscoe “Fatty” Arbuckle, Wallace Beery and Buster Keaton.
Tagline: Nobody loves a fat man.
The Plot…
Slim Hoover is the Sheriff of the frontier town Lonesome Pine. Although adept with a gun, Slim often uses his quick wit to get the drop on the bad hombres.
Dick Lane is almost ready to head back to Lonesome Pine after success prospecting alone in the desert. Once home Dick plans to marry Echo Allen. Unfortunately, that is not to be. Mexican bandits led by the “half-breed” Buck McKee shoot, rob and leave Dick for dead.
When Dick doesn’t return, Jack Payson tells Echo he will ride out and find him. As Jack is about to go Buck McKee rides up. Buck says he was prospecting with Dick when they were attacked by Mexican bandits. He says that he and Dick put up a fight, but there were too many. Dick was shot. Before he died, Dick asked Buck to escape and bring word to Echo.
What Buck doesn’t know is that although Dick was near death, Mexican Federales saved him. It will take years for Dick to recover enough to return home. Meanwhile Jack and Echo fall in love. After three years pass, Echo agrees to marry Jack.
On the night Echo and Jack are to be wed, Dick returns. It turns out the bandits didn’t get all of Dick’s gold. Dick has enough cash to pay Jack the $3,000.00 he owes him. Jack and Dick meet. Jack accepts the $3,000.00. Dick learns that Echo and Jack are about to be wed. Since no one else has seen him, Dick leaves.
Meanwhile, Buck McKee decides the wedding will provide cover to rob the express agent’s office which is full of cash. The robbery goes sideways when Buck kills the express agent. Buck takes the money. He then heads to the wedding so he will have an alibi.
The robbery and murder are discovered. The wedding guests are shocked. Buck falls under suspicion. But Buck has seen the large amount of cash Jack has hidden. Buck tells everyone about it. Suddenly Jack becomes the number one suspect. Jack can’t explain the cash without admitting that Dick is still alive. That could cost him Echo.
Buck incites the crowd to get justice NOW. The mob gets worked up for a necktie party.
It will be up to Sheriff Slim to save Jack and see justice is served.
Thoughts (beware of spoilers)…
The Round Up was Fatty Arbuckle’s first feature film. Arbuckle had made over 120 comedy shorts prior to this film.
The Round Up was first a successful Broadway play that starred Fatty’s cousin Macklin Arbuckle. Tom Forman adapted the play and co-starred as Jack. Because Fatty’s next comedy wasn’t ready, he was tapped to play Sheriff Slim. The role earned him some of the best reviews of his career.
The Round Up was the first film to be shot in Lonesome Pine, California. Over 300 more westerns would use the location.
Buster Keaton appears (uncredited) in two scenes as one of the attacking Indians.
The Round Up (1920) rates 4 of 5 stars.

