
The Man Who Cheated Himself (1950)
Director: Felix E. Feist
Screenplay: Seton I. Miller, Philip MacDonald
Stars: Lee J. Cobb, Jane Wyatt, John Dall, Lisa Howard, Tito Vuolo, Marjorie Bennett, Alan Wells, Morgan Farley, and Howard Negley.
Tagline: For a woman like this … a man would do anything … even murder.
The Overview: Beware of spoilers…
Andy Cullen (Dall) newly promoted to Detective is assigned to partner with his brother, Lt. Ed Cullen (Cobb). Andy is a hot shot looking to prove himself. Their first case involves the murder of Howard Frazer, found shot dead at the airport. An older couple witnessed a man driving away from the body.
Ed says the case looks like a robbery gone wrong, but Andy’s not ready to jump to that conclusion. A few things don’t feel right. After Ed and Andy talk to the dead man’s wife, Lois (Wyatt), Andy is even more sure something’s not on the level. What Andy doesn’t know is that Lois killed her husband and Ed moved the body from her house to the airport. Ed’s in an affair with Lois and thought he could cover up the crime. But with Andy on the case and digging deeper…
Lee J. Cobb’s Ed Cullen is a cynical cop who knows his affair won’t turn into anything more. Yet, he feels compelled to help his lover cover up the murder. The screenwriters do an excellent job of making it look like things can be explained in a way that gets the case moving away from Lois, but then Andy finds another clue that takes it closer. Kudos to screenwriters Seton I. Miller and Philip MacDonald, as well as director Felix E. Feist for creating a scene where a book’s binding creates tension and suspense. The final scene with Lois talking to her attorney and then getting a light from Cullen is worth the price of admission.
The Man Who Cheated Himself earns 4 of 5 stars.

